home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=89TT2753>
- <link 93TG0008>
- <link 93HT0786>
- <link 90TT1931>
- <link 90TT0194>
- <title>
- Oct. 23, 1989: Boom, Boom, Ka-Boom!
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1989
- Oct. 23, 1989 Is Government Dead?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- BUSINESS, Page 66
- Boom, Boom, Ka-boom!
- </hdr><body>
- <p>Panicked by a faltering buyout deal and a whiff of inflation,
- the stock market posts its worst loss since the '87 crash and
- provokes fears of a bearish season to come
- </p>
- <p>By John Greenwald
- </p>
- <p> The day was star-crossed: Friday the 13th in the month of
- October, on the eve of the second anniversary of a devastating
- market crash. "I'm telling you, psychology is really funny.
- People get crazy in situations like that," said portfolio
- strategist Elaine Garzarelli. Last week Friday the 13th lived
- up to its frightful reputation. After drifting lower at a sleepy
- pace for most of the day, the Dow Jones industrial average
- abruptly lurched into a hair-raising sky dive in the final hour
- of trading. By the time the 4 p.m. closing bell halted the rout,
- the index had dropped a nightmarish 190.58 points, or nearly 7%,
- to close at 2569.26.
- </p>
- <p> The sell-off was the sharpest since the market plunged 508
- points on Oct. 19, 1987. In terms of points, it was the second
- largest loss in Wall Street history; in percentage, the day
- ranked twelfth worst. "It's total emotional and psychological
- chaos," said Eugene Peroni, an analyst with Janney Montgomery
- Scott, a Philadelphia brokerage firm. "People are dumping
- everything. A great deal of money is being lost."
- </p>
- <p> The drop invited instant comparison with the month's two
- historic calamities: the 1987 collapse on Oct. 19 and the 1929
- debacle on Oct. 29. Particularly gnawing was the memory that
- 1987's Black Monday was preceded by a Friday plunge of 108.35
- points. Last week's drop-off rekindled fears that an era of
- heedless borrowing by corporations and the Federal Government
- might finally be coming to grief. At the very least, the rout
- reminded investors that the stock market is a volatile place
- where fortunes can vanish at the touch of a computer key. After
- one frantic hour of selling conducted to a large extent by
- program trades, nearly $200 billion of stock values were wiped
- out last week.
- </p>
- <p> The Bush Administration moved swiftly to avert any sense of
- crisis after the market closed. Declared Treasury Secretary
- Nicholas Brady: "It's important to recognize that today's stock
- market decline doesn't signal any fundamental change in the
- condition of the economy. The economy remains well balanced,
- and the outlook is for continued moderate growth." But
- Massachusetts Democrat Edward Markey, who chairs a House
- subcommittee on telecommunications and finance, vowed to hold
- hearings this week on the stock market slide. Said he: "This is
- the second heart attack. My hope is that before we have the
- inevitable third heart attack, we pay attention to these
- problems."
- </p>
- <p> Experts found no shortage of culprits to blame for the
- latest debacle. A series of downbeat realizations converged on
- Friday, ranging from signs of a new burst of inflation to
- sagging corporate profits to troubles in the junk-bond market
- that has fueled major takeovers. The singular event that shook
- investors was the faltering of a $6.75 billion labor-management
- buyout of UAL, the parent company of United Airlines, the second
- largest U.S. carrier. "That's when all hell broke loose," said
- Robert Newman, a floor trader for Equitrade Partners. "It was
- very reminiscent of something I do not care to think about."
- </p>
- <p> On one point most thoughtful Wall Streeters agreed: the
- market had reached such dizzying heights that a correction of
- some sort seemed almost inevitable. Propelled by favorable
- economic news and a wave of multibillion-dollar takeovers,
- stocks had soared more than 1,000 points since the 1987 crash.
- But by last August some Wall Streeters were clearly worried.
- Noted Donald Stone, a floor specialist for Lasker, Stone &
- Stern: "I've been on the trading floor for 39 years, and I've
- never seen the market go up so fast for so long without a major
- break." Yet the bulls kept on running. Just last Monday the
- market closed at a historic peak of 2791.41, its fifth record
- high in as many sessions.
- </p>
- <p> The looming anniversary of 1987's crash had prompted many
- on Wall Street to search for comparisons between 1987's boom and
- this year's. In an investor newsletter dated Oct. 1, Shearson
- Lehman Hutton cited twelve ways in which this year's rally
- seemed more likely to last. Among them:
- </p>
- <p> -- Interest rates were rising then, while they are stable or
- falling now.
- </p>
- <p> -- The economy was growing unsustainably in 1987, but more
- gradually this year.
- </p>
- <p> -- Investor sentiment was wildly bullish then, and far more
- cautious now.
- </p>
- <p> Yet this year's rally has rested on some shaky foundations.
- Chief among them is the relentless pace of corporate takeovers,
- which enriched everyone on Wall Street, from stockholders to
- investment bankers. But the buyouts have been fueled by
- financing from a junk-bond market that was severely weakened
- last month when Canadian developer Robert Campeau nearly
- defaulted on $1.27 billion of debt payments on loans that he had
- used to acquire Allied Stores and Federated Department Stores.
- In the wake of Campeau's problems, the money for new takeovers
- has begun to dry up.
- </p>
- <p> Meanwhile, the Government's chief early-warning gauge of
- inflation indicated last week that the U.S. economy may be
- headed for trouble. The Labor Department said its Producer Price
- Index rose 0.9% in September, or about 10% on an annual basis,
- to break a three-month string of declining wholesale prices.
- Earlier in the week, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan
- suggested that the Fed remains wary of inflation and therefore
- would be averse to easing interest rates. That was not what Wall
- Street wanted to hear.
- </p>
- <p> The heaviest blow to the market came Friday afternoon. In
- a three-paragraph statement, UAL said a labor-management group
- headed by Chairman Stephen Wolf had failed to get enough
- financing to acquire United. Several banks had apparently balked
- at the deal", which was to be partly financed through junk
- bonds. The takeover group said it would submit a revised bid "in
- the near term," but the announcement stunned investors who had
- come to view the United deal as the latest sure thing in the
- 1980s buyout binge. Said John Downey, a trader at the Chicago
- Board Options Exchange: "The airline stocks have looked like
- attractive takeover targets. But with the United deal in
- trouble, everyone started to wonder what other deals might not
- go through."
- </p>
- <p> Nowhere was the shock greater than on Wall Street, where
- some traders had left work early Friday to enjoy a balmy Indian
- summer day. "I was on the floor until 2:30," said specialist
- Stone. "The trading was so quiet that I decided to go home." But
- by the time he got there shortly after 3, the damage was already
- out of control. "I saw quite a bit of panic selling," said
- Muriel Siebert, who heads a discount brokerage that bears her
- name. UAL shares fell 5 1/2 points before trading in its stock
- was halted because the number of sellers overwhelmed buyers.
- Delta Air Lines, a frequently rumored takeover target, dropped
- 7 3/4.
- </p>
- <p> Some safeguards installed in the market after the 1987
- crash may have helped cushion last week's fall. In Chicago the
- Mercantile Exchange twice halted trading in S&P 500 futures
- contracts, which represent the stocks in the Standard & Poor's
- 500 index. The automatic cutoffs, or "circuit breakers," slowed
- the contracts' drop. In 1987 parallel free falls in New York
- and Chicago, which are linked by computerized trading programs,
- had aggravated the collapse. But last week some Chicago traders
- claimed that the stoppages in futures trading restricted the
- ability of some investors to hedge their losses, forcing them
- to dump stocks and exacerbating the selling frenzy in Manhattan.
- </p>
- <p> Many investors, especially short-term speculators, were
- badly shaken. The biggest losers were Wall Street arbitragers,
- who make money by buying the stock of takeover targets and
- selling it at a higher price when the deals go through. The high
- anxiety about the junk-bond market sent the stocks of takeover
- targets plunging across the board. "The arbs got their heads
- handed to them," said Anson Beard, the chief trader for Morgan
- Stanley. "Very few anticipated that the UAL buyout could fail."
- Small investors suffered less because they have been less active
- in the market since the 1987 crash.
- </p>
- <p> The market drop echoed around the world. In Tokyo, Noriko
- Hama, a senior staffer at the Mitsubishi Research Institute,
- warned that "it could be very hard to stop" the Wall Street
- plunge from sending ripples through foreign stock exchanges.
- Tokyo's volatile Nikkei index fell 445.02 points last Thursday,
- its sharpest drop since June. The index rebounded 320.97 points
- on Friday to close at 35,116.02, down 93.33 for the week.
- </p>
- <p> To many investors, the most disturbing aspect of the Wall
- Street slide was its breathless speed. "We have a history of
- market bubbles and panics," says Allen Sinai, chief economist
- for the Boston Company Economic Advisors. "But because of the
- advance in communications, corrections that used to take days,
- weeks or months now take minutes. Any positive or negative
- events get communicated in seconds." Sinai added that while "a
- drop of 190 points is shocking and a source of great anxiety and
- nervousness, it doesn't suggest that the sky is going to fall.
- The lesson of 1987 is that financial markets often have a life
- of their own."
- </p>
- <p> Brokerage houses rushed to convey a similar message to
- their customers after the plunge. Merrill Lynch urged investors
- to stay in the market for the long haul. The company recommended
- that customers split their investments among Treasury bonds and
- stocks of companies in such growing fields as health care and
- pollution control. "Looking for the quick killing is one of the
- surest ways of getting hurt in the stock market," says chairman
- William Schreyer. "One of the things we encouraged our clients
- to do after Oct. 19, 1987, was to stay with the market, think
- long-term and get professional advice."
- </p>
- <p> Many investors seemed ready last week to stick with the
- market for the long haul. John Markese, research director for
- the Chicago-based American Association of Individual Investors,
- said most of the group's 110,000 members "did nothing" after the
- 1987 crash, "and I suspect they will do nothing this time." In
- San Francisco, investor Robert Simon said of Friday's drop, "It
- tells me the market is overheated. I have been wary since 1987,"
- Simon noted, "and I am more wary today." Nonetheless, he said,
- he remained as heavily invested in stocks as he was two years
- ago.
- </p>
- <p> Some market watchers viewed the drop as a signal of a
- coming U.S. downturn. While the economy avoided a slump after
- the 1987 crash, these moneymen fear that the U.S. may not be as
- lucky again. "I believe a recession of some sort is imminent,"
- says Richard Huebner, a senior vice president of the Hanifen,
- Imhoff brokerage in Denver. "It didn't happen in 1987, but this
- time the environment is changed. Our economy was overheated
- then. This time it is slowing down, which makes recession more
- likely. The market appears to be telling us that it is six to
- nine months away."
- </p>
- <p> But other experts considered Friday's free fall to be far
- less worrisome. Said James Wilcox, an associate professor of
- business administration at the University of California,
- Berkeley: "My own opinion is that the market was overvalued by
- at least 200 points and that basically this is a reversion to
- sanity. I look upon it as a breath of thoughtful fresh air."
- Peter Lynch, manager of the $11 billion Fidelity Magellan fund,
- was upbeat too. "America is not a basket case," Lynch said. "The
- only thing that could bring a major decline is if inflation went
- back into double digits."
- </p>
- <p> In Congress the stock drop rekindled fears of a financial
- collapse that have flickered since the 1987 crash. Michigan
- Democrat Donald Riegle, chairman of the Senate Banking
- Committee, said the Friday decline might indicate "a marked
- change in market psychology" about the value of stocks that
- "would be a very important development, to say the least."
- Riegle, who this month called for a Government study of the role
- of junk bonds in leveraged buyouts, said the plunge indicated
- that "there's a lot more at work here than the LBO story." But
- a senior White House official insisted the drop simply reflected
- "the falling through of the UAL deal." He added: "We're
- confident the market will straighten itself out."
- </p>
- <p> Wall Street, Washington and investors around the world will
- be watching the market with nervous anticipation to see whether
- it can shake off its anxiety attack. The Federal Reserve will
- monitor events carefully to determine whether it should come to
- the rescue with a dose of easier money, as it did in 1987 to
- restore confidence. One fervent hope was that high-rolling
- investors would come roaring back into the market, looking for
- bargains. But while it was easy to attribute last week's chiller
- to everything from program trading to superstition about Friday
- the 13th, there was a deeper message: confidence in the Stock
- market will remain shaky as long as the U.S. economy rests on
- a mountain of debt that neither politicians in Washington nor
- business leaders on Wall Street seem willing to confront.
- </p>
- <p>--Bernard Baumaohl, Frederick Ungeheuer and Jane Van
- Tassel/New York </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-